Your search Notice: This Summary Order May Not Be Cited As Precedential Authority, but May Be Called to the Attention of the Court in a Subsequent Stage of This Case, in a Related Case, or in Any Case for Purposes of Collateral Estoppel or Res Judicata. See Second Circuit Rule 0.23.neil Mcnaughton, Plaintiff-appellant, v. Rudolph Giuliani, As Mayor of the City of New York, Brianjoseph, As Commissioner of Finance, Randy Levine, Ascommissioner of Labor Relations, Simon Salas, Devora Cohn,patricia Mcm. Bartels, Muriel Goode-trufant, Todd Bromberg,the City of New York, the New York City Department Offinance, and the New York City Office of Labor Relations,defendants-appellees did not match any document.