Your search Brenda Berkman, on Behalf of Herself and a Class Consistingof All Similarly- Situated Women,plaintiff-appellee-cross-appellant, v. the City of New York; Edward I. Koch, Individually and Asmayor of the City of New York; New York City Firedepartment, Augustus Beekman, Individually and As Firecommissioner of the City of New York; New York Citydepartment of Personnel; Michael Nadel, Individually and Asdirector of Personnel of the City of New York; Thomasroche, Individually and As Former Director of Personnel Ofthe City of New York; Civil Service Commission of the Cityof New York, Defendants-appellants-cross-appellees,anduniformed Firefighters Association, Local 94, Firefighterseligibles Association, List No. 1162, Inc.,defendants-intervenors-appellants-cross- Appellees,andjames T. Ahrens, Defendant-intervenor did not match any document.