Your search Ralph J. Bavaro; Elizabeth C. Hogan Plaintiffs-appellants, v. George E. Pataki, Individually, and As Governor of the Stateof New York; James G. Natoli, Individually, and As Directorof the State Operations of the State of New York; Barbaraann Debuono, Individually, and As Commissioner of the Newyork State Department of Health; Karen Schimke,individually, and As Executive Deputy Commissioner of Thenew York State Department of Health; Jerry Jasinski,individually, and As Acting General Counsel of the New Yorkstate Department of Health; State of New York; Department of Health, did not match any document.